Saying Goodbye to a Tree

Nearly 4 years ago, I planted two bare root apple trees, Beverly Hills and golden delicious, with great hope that they would thrive in my backyard (, as has my 3-in-1 apple tree. Unfortunately, this has not been the case. Both fell victim to cedar apple rust and despite years of treatment, the Beverly Hills tree has continued a downward trend, with a weak root system and producing fruit that would not survive to maturity.  The golden delicious has also been struggling, but has been able to produce delicious fruit to that survive to maturity. Although I’ll be keeping my eye on the golden delicious, today was the day I decided to say goodbye to the Beverly Hills apple tree and dug it out.

While it’s a sad event, it’s the nature of gardening – not every plant survives, despite efforts to keep it healthy. I’d probably kept it too long, but really wanted to give it a chance to turn things around, which didn’t happen. Investing in the care of a declining plant may be helpful in the short run if improvement in health is evident shortly after restorative efforts; otherwise, it’s better to put place efforts into the healthy, stronger plants. My 3-in-1 apple tree was also hit by cedar apple rust but has been able to fight back and produce quite a lot of apples. Loving trees as I do, especially fruit trees, I know the decision was right for the health of my entire backyard food garden. Goodbye, Beverly Hills apple tree.

CONSUMER ALERT UPDATE:  Apple seeds are highly toxic if ingested. More information on toxic plants can be found here:


Quince Stricken by Brown Rot

Such sad news when a crop is wiped out. My 3-in-1 pear trees, this year, has been producing primarily quince fruits. The two trees have been stricken with brown rot, destroying the fruit. In the beginning, the fruits were growing seemingly normally. But then, small brown spots started to appear and take over the fruit.

During these past warm weeks, I have slept with the window open. I kept getting startled by the thuds of quince fruits dropping from the tree, one by one. Quite a gardening nightmare! When I would inspect the results the following morning, the ground was littered with quince, some still green with no visible brown spots, and others with large brown spots. With over 100 fruits between them, I think I’ve enjoyed just a handful of normal fruits – the rest have been wasted by brown rot.

By the way, it is a rather shocking event to cut into what looks to be a normal, unaffected quince and find that it has, in fact, been ravaged by brown rot. The photo on the right is what a clear case of brown-rotted fruit looks like from their exterior – an awful mess.

Update 10/26/2013: In my case, if the brown rot has just started infecting the fruit, it may not be obvious if you quickly pick the fruit.  The browning may be quite pale in color at that stage. Furthermore, as I later discovered, brown rot is a likely outcome if your quince are attacked by the snout beetle known as plum curculio. These beetles drill holes in your quince. The larvae eat through the fruit, making brown rot infection likely.

The following website provides excellent photos of what a quince, affected by plum curculio,  looks like from the inside out, and is exactly what I have seen with my own eyes:

Your quince fruit  is doomed and should be discarded if they look anything like what is in my photo, and/or if they are covered in tiny holes.

Cause of Brown Rot: Brown rot is caused by a fungus, Monilinia fructicola, and attacks not just quince and related apples and pears, but also stone fruits. I’ve not seen leaf damage, however.  I will have to find a suitable fungicide to treat my trees and hope that the next year brings happier, healthier news for these poor trees.

Update 10/26/2013: Treatment of brown rot depends on whether or not your tree is fruiting. If your tree is fruiting, physically removing brown-rotted fruit from the tree and pruning affected branches is recommended, being sure that this discarded vegetation is kept far away from the “treated” tree to prevent reinfection.

If your tree is not fruiting, remove blighted blossoms (which will be brown instead of white/pink), branches, and twigs (which may have cankers). You may spray the leaves (upper and undersides) and branches of your entire tree with a commercially available fungicide. Please note that these fungicides have different degrees of toxicity, so may injure your health (poisonous) if ingested. For that reason, do not spray fungicide on fruit or a fruiting tree.

More information on how brown rot affects  quince, apple, and pear trees can be found here:

Information on diseases of various fruit trees can be found on this helpful website, including information on disease control/treatment:

CONSUMER ALERT UPDATE:  The quince is related to apples and pears, whose seeds are highly toxic if ingested.  For this reason, do not ingest the seeds of these fruits.

More information on toxic plants can be found here:

Garden Fairy Farm

Organic gardening and the preservation of biodiversity


Walk and Bike in France.

Photo Nature Blog

Nature Photography by Jeffrey Foltice

moments clicked

Some of the best moments captured

Cindy Hollett, Writer

Mystery Writer, Cape Cod

The Stay-at-home Scientist

Science, Gardening, Work-Life Balance

Sunny Sleevez

Sun Protection & Green Info

The Scottish Country Garden

An occasional blog from a walled country garden in South East Scotland

Earth Citizen

Spreading peace by dropping Truth bombs

Arthur in the Garden.

Gardening and Cooking inside the beltline in Raleigh, North Carolina.


Jardinería en la costa del sol is the best place for your personal blog or business site.

%d bloggers like this: